Research · 100 coaches’ Instagram accounts
I read 100 coaches’ Instagram accounts, post by post. Here’s what works.
By Hamza JavedAccounts checked 20 Nov 2026Published
The short version
Reels are most of what active coaches post (57%), and a typical reel reaches about 1 in 10 followers. Smaller accounts reach a bigger share than big ones, and 29 of the 80 active accounts had a recent reel seen by more people than follow them. Where it leaks is the next step: 33 bios don’t say what to do, 51 send people to a page of links, and every “comment a word” needs someone to reply. The reach is there. The step after it is where coaches lose people.
- 57%
- Of recent posts on active accounts are reels
- 1 in 10
- Followers a typical reel reaches (median views ÷ followers)
- 29
- Of the 80 active accounts had a recent reel seen by more people than follow them
- 33
- Out of 100 bios give no next step at all
Why I did this
When I went through 115 coaching websites, 55 of them linked to an Instagram account. For a lot of coaches, Instagram is where a new client first finds them, long before the website. So I wanted to see what coaches actually post there, what gets watched, and what a new follower is asked to do next.
I read 100 coaches’ accounts by hand: the bio, the link, the pinned posts, the newest posts and the view counts on their reels. No names here: the point is the pattern, not any one coach.
What I found
Small accounts reach a bigger share of their followers than big ones
On accounts under 10K followers, a typical reel was seen by about 22.3% of the follower count. Between 10K and 100K it was 8.6%, and at 100K and up only 2.2%. Of the 80 active accounts, 29 had a recent reel watched by more people than follow them. Two clear cases: a career coach with 6.7K followers whose reel about writing a self-review reached 1.5 million views in nine days, and a sobriety coach with 860 followers whose reels reached 112,000 and 198,000 in the same week.
Typical reel views as a share of followers Overall: about 1 in 10 followers
Under 10K followers28 active · typical reel 810 views22.3%10K to 100K27 active · typical reel 3,080 views8.6%100K and up25 active · typical reel 10,400 views2.2%Median of each active account’s recent non-pinned reels, divided by its followers, then the median for each group. 80 active accounts.
The fix: Stop waiting to “grow first”. Instagram shows reels to people who don’t follow you yet, so a small account can reach new clients from its first month.
Reels are the default, and a third of active coaches post nearly every day
Of the 715 newest posts on the 80 active accounts, 408 were reels, 183 carousels and 124 single images. 36 accounts were mostly reels. The median active account posted 9 reels in the last 30 days, and 27 posted 10 or more. Carousels haven’t gone away: 16 accounts led with them, mostly text slides people save and share.
The 715 newest posts on 80 active accounts 57%26%17%- Reels (408)
- Carousels (183)
- Single images (124)
Reels posted in the last 30 days, per active account
6138262701–23–56–910+Formats count the 9 newest non-pinned posts per account. Reel counts are reels posted in the 30 days before 20 Nov 2026, counted up to 12.
The fix: Make reels the core and keep a carousel or two a week for the ideas people want to keep. The median active coach here posted about two reels a week, and a third posted nearly every day. How content automation works for coaches
The bio is the homepage, and a third of them don’t say what to do next
33 of 100 bios have no next step: no “book a call”, no free download, no word to DM. 51 of 100 send people to a page of links, so a visitor who is ready has to choose again before they can act. 59 of 100 say who they help, and 45 of 100 include a number, credential or press mention.
Out of 100 coach profiles Bio has a clear next step67Bio says who they help59Bio has a number, credential or press line45Link goes straight to one page44The other 51 links go to a page of links, and 5 have no link at all.
The fix: Write the bio like the top of a sales page: who you help, the result, one line of proof, then one action. Point the link straight at that action, not at a list. What 115 coaching websites offer a new enquirer
“Comment a word” is the new “book a call”, and the reply is where it can break
36 of 100 accounts ask people to comment or DM a keyword (“Comment COPILOT and I’ll send you…”, “DM me RISE”). Across the whole study their reels reached a slightly smaller share of followers (8.5% against 12.2%), but between 10K and 100K followers they reached more (12% against 7.2%), so asking doesn’t reliably cost reach either way. The smallest account in the study to do it well, with 860 followers, ends every reel with one of three words: one books a call, one sends a free guide. But every keyword is a promise that someone will reply, often at 11pm or on a Sunday.
The fix: If you ask for a keyword, send the promised link the moment it arrives, automatically, then follow up a day later with the people who didn’t open it. How fast should coaches reply to enquiries?
Accounts that only sell get the least reach
Accounts where nearly every recent post was a sales pitch (“join the webinar”, “enrollment is open”, “DM me for details”) had some of the lowest reach in the study. One, with 28K followers and several promotional posts a day, had a median of 76 views per reel. A money coach with 454K followers whose recent posts are almost all event promos gets 100 to 1,800 views a reel. The same pattern shows up inside one account: on a dating coach’s account with 2.5 million followers, the two recent reels that opened with a sales line (“Comment ASK to…”, “Comment 320 to join my coaching group”) got 35,000 and 48,000 views, against a typical 176,000 for the rest. The accounts with the highest reach mostly taught one useful thing per reel and asked for the sale at the end.
One dating coach, 2.5M followers: views per reel Typical reelteaching, stories, reminders176K“Comment 320 to join my coaching group…”opened with the sale48K“Comment ASK to have me on speed dial…”opened with the sale35KThe two sales-first reels are from the same week as the rest. Typical = median of the 12 newest non-pinned reels.
The fix: Teach first, then invite. One clear tip or answer per reel, with the offer in the last line or the caption.
An old viral reel doesn’t keep paying
Several big accounts have pinned reels with one to seven million views and recent reels with a few thousand. A men’s dating coach with 290K followers has pinned reels at 4.5 and 6.8 million views, while his recent reels get a median of about 4,800. A business coach with 484K followers has pinned reels at up to 1.4 million and recent ones at about 3,800. A large following built on one viral moment doesn’t mean the next post gets seen.
Best pinned reel against a typical recent reel Men’s dating coach, 290K followers6.8Mpinned4,800recentEmotional intelligence coach, 136K1.7Mpinned860recentBusiness coach, 484K followers1.4Mpinned3,800recentPinned reels are often years old. Typical recent = median of the newest non-pinned reels.
The fix: Judge your account on your last ten reels, not your best one. Pin the posts that explain who you help and what to do next, not just the ones with the biggest numbers.
Timely and repeatable beat random
A career coach whose reels usually get about 1,500 views posted about layoffs at a well-known company that week and got 54,400. A matchmaker opens and closes nearly every reel with the same lines about who they are and where to book, and those reels get a median of 240,000 views. Others run weekly series, like a client win every Wednesday or a coaching question of the week. An intuitive coach whose usual reels get 1,000 to 5,000 views got 41,000 and 63,000 on two reels about the current astrology season. A numbered “Day 1 to Day 4” series on its own didn’t lift views, so a series still needs good topics.
The fix: Keep a fixed shape (same intro, same sign-off, same weekly slot) and fill it with what your clients are talking about this week.
Plenty of coaches go quiet
20 of 100 accounts hadn’t posted in the last 30 days, and 9 hadn’t posted for more than a year. Two of those still have 60K and 180K followers, several still show up near the top of Instagram search, and one has emptied its grid, leaving only a bio and a link. Separately, 6 call themselves coaches in the bio, but none of their recent posts are about coaching.
All 100 accounts, one square each - Posted in the last 30 days: 80
- Quiet for 1 to 12 months: 10
- Quiet for over a year, or grid emptied: 10
The fix: Treat posting like any other part of the business: a plan, a batch, a schedule. If it depends on finding time each day, it stops. Case study: 117 reels with nobody posting by hand
Six reel openers that reached far past the follower count
For every reel I read, I noted the first line of the caption next to its views. These six patterns reached the most people compared with the size of the account. Each one comes with a fill-in version you can use. The × figure is views divided by followers.
The annoying task your client is doing this week
1.5M views on 6,665 followers · 225×
“The absolute worst part of writing a self-review is remembering what you did last year” (Career coach)
Use it: “The worst part of [seasonal task] is [specific pain]. Here’s the fix.”
A plain truth from lived experience, then a numbered list
112K views on 860 followers · 130×
“Living sober is realizing alcohol isn’t the answer to everything.” (Sobriety coach)
Use it: “Living [the result] is realizing [old belief] isn’t true.” Then 5 short lessons.
“Psychology says…” with a number
161K views on 1,366 followers · 118×
“Psychology says these 6 phrases quietly kill the sale” (Business coach)
Use it: “Psychology says these [N] [habits] quietly [ruin the result].”
This-or-that question
3,213 views on 69 followers · 47×
“Physical cheating versus emotional betrayal. Where do you draw the line?” (Matchmaker, new account)
Use it: “[Option A] or [Option B]? Where do you draw the line?”
“Respectfully, if you’ve never…”
14K views on 860 followers · 16×
“Respectfully, if you’ve never had to rebuild your life while everyone else thought you were losing your mind…” (Sobriety coach)
Use it: “Respectfully, if you’ve never [hard thing your client lives], this won’t make sense yet.”
The news your clients are talking about
54K views on 4,032 followers · 13×
A reel on layoffs at a well-known company, posted the same week (Career coach)
Use it: “[Event] just happened. If you’re [client], do this now.”
What this means if you’re a coach
Getting seen on Instagram is less of a problem than most coaches think, even with a small account. The gap is the same one I found on coaching websites: someone is interested, and then they have to work out what to do, or wait for a reply. If I were fixing one account, I’d do it in this order:
Rewrite the bio as a one-line offer. Who you help, the result, one proof point and one action. Point the link at that action.
Pick one free thing and one keyword. Use the same word at the end of every reel, so people learn it.
Reply to every keyword instantly. Send the link the moment someone comments or DMs, then follow up with the people who didn’t open it.
Post reels on a fixed rhythm. A few a week, in a repeatable shape, about what your clients are dealing with right now.
Teach first, sell last. One useful idea per reel, with the invitation in the last line.
All the figures
Out of 100 accounts unless the row says otherwise. Post formats and posting rhythm count only the 80 accounts that posted in the last 30 days.
| On the account | Figure |
|---|---|
| Accounts studied | 100 |
| Posted in the last 30 days | 80 (80%) |
| Median followers | 25,900 |
| Newest posts that are reels (active accounts, 715 posts) | 57% |
| Newest posts that are carousels | 26% |
| Newest posts that are single images | 17% |
| Reels in the last 30 days (median, active accounts) | 9 |
| Typical reel views as a share of followers (median) | 9.8% |
| Under 10K followers: share of followers / typical views | 22.3% / 810 |
| 10K to 100K: share of followers / typical views | 8.6% / 3,080 |
| 100K and up: share of followers / typical views | 2.2% / 10,400 |
| Had a recent reel with more views than followers (active accounts) | 29 (36%) |
| Bio has a clear next step | 67 (67%) |
| Bio says who they help | 59 (59%) |
| Bio has a number, credential or press line | 45 (45%) |
| Link goes to a page of links | 51 (51%) |
| Link goes straight to one page | 44 (44%) |
| Ask for a keyword by comment or DM | 36 (36%) |
| Use all three pinned posts | 52 (52%) |
What the 67 bios with a next step ask for: book or apply for a call (22), a free download, class, quiz or guide (19), send a keyword by DM or comment (6), something else (a course, an event, a community, a newsletter, “start here”) (20).
Coaching areas covered: life (23), dating and relationships (20), business (13), career (9), wellness and sobriety (8), mindset (6), money (4), leadership (4), divorce (3), ADHD (2), confidence (2), speaking (2), burnout (2), parenting (1), spiritual (1). Followers ranged from 20 to 2.5 million.
How I did it
- I found coaches through Instagram’s own search (“life coach”, “career coach for women”, “dating coach”, “ADHD coach”, “business coach for women”, “divorce coach”, “burnout coach”, “sobriety coach”, “money coach” and similar) and through published lists of coaches to follow. I kept to English-language accounts, mostly in the US, UK and Canada.
- I read every account by hand in a normal browser, one at a time, in batches of about ten with breaks in between. No scraping tools.
- For each account I noted the bio, where the link goes, the pinned posts, the format of the nine newest non-pinned posts, and the captions for calls to action.
- Reel views come from the play counts on each account’s Reels tab: up to 12 of the newest reels, leaving out pinned ones. “Typical” means the median, so one viral reel doesn’t skew it.
- Post dates come from each post’s ID, which encodes when it was published.
- A “next step” counted only when the bio told the visitor to do something specific: book, apply, download, take a quiz, or send a word. A link on its own didn’t count.
- 13 handles from the published lists were deleted, renamed or now belong to someone else, and several follower counts in those lists were far out of date. I also left out accounts that turned out not to be coaches (an influencer, a lawyer, an author, a brand page) and accounts posting in other languages, and used only what was on the profile that day.
Limits
- Public play counts are not the same as the reach, saves or sales a coach sees in their own insights.
- 100 accounts is a small sample, and it leans towards coaches who show up in search and in “who to follow” lists. Most are in the US, with some in the UK and Canada and a few elsewhere.
- I read captions and looked at posts, but I didn’t watch every video in full.
- I didn’t comment or send any keywords, so I can’t say how fast these coaches actually reply.
- This shows what goes together, not what causes what. A reel can do well for reasons that aren’t visible from outside.
- Accounts checked 20 Nov 2026. Instagram changes quickly.