How fast should you reply to a new client enquiry?
By Hamza JavedUpdated 3 min read
The short answer
Within an hour, and an instant automatic reply makes that easy. A Harvard Business Review study of online sales leads found that companies that contacted a lead within an hour were nearly seven times as likely to have a meaningful conversation with a decision maker as companies that tried an hour later. For a coach, an automatic reply in seconds plus a personal reply the same day covers this.
Key points
- Acknowledge every enquiry within minutes, automatically.
- Say exactly when you will reply personally, and keep that promise.
- Include a booking link so ready clients do not have to wait for you.
- Use a holiday version when you are away, with a date for your reply.
What the research found
In “The Short Life of Online Sales Leads” (Harvard Business Review, 2011), James Oldroyd, Kristina McElheran and David Elkington looked at how quickly companies responded to leads that came in online. Firms that tried to contact a lead within an hour were nearly seven times as likely to have a meaningful conversation with a key decision maker as firms that tried an hour later, and more than 60 times as likely as firms that waited 24 hours or longer.
The study looked at companies in general, not coaches. The lesson still carries over: interest fades fast, and the person who answers first is often the one who gets the conversation.
An automatic reply you can copy
Set this as your contact form’s automatic reply email, or as your auto-reply in the inbox where enquiries arrive.
Hi [name], thanks for reaching out! I’ve got your message and I’ll reply personally by [time] tomorrow. Here’s how my coaching works: [link]. You can pick a time for a free call here: [booking link].
- It confirms the message arrived, so they stop wondering.
- It gives a clear time for your personal reply.
- It answers the first question, “how does this work?”, with a link.
- It lets a ready client book straight away.
When you are away
A plain “I’m out of office” leaves an enquiry stuck for days. Give people a next step instead.
Hi, thanks for your message! I’m away until [date] and I’ll reply personally on [date]. If you’d like to talk sooner, you can book a free call for after I’m back here: [booking link]. Answers to common questions are here: [link].
How to make a fast reply a habit
Send every enquiry to one place
Website form, email and social messages should all land where you will see them. Enquiries spread over four apps are the ones that wait.
Turn on the automatic reply
Use the template above. It buys you time without leaving anyone waiting in silence.
Set two reply times a day
For example, 9am and 4pm. With the auto-reply promising “by tomorrow”, two set times are enough to keep that promise.
Say it on your contact page
A line such as “I reply personally within one working day” sets expectations before anyone writes.
Common questions
Is an automatic reply enough on its own?
No. It buys you time, but the personal reply still matters. Promise a specific time in the automatic reply and keep that promise.
What should I put in my first personal reply?
Answer their question directly, ask one question back about their goal, and give one clear next step, usually a link to book a short call.
Do I need to reply on weekends?
Not personally. Let the automatic reply cover weekends and say when you will reply. Clear expectations matter more than being always on.
Written by Hamza Javed, a software engineer who builds automation for coaches and small education businesses: replies to new enquiries, follow-ups and content that publishes itself. More about Hamza