How to follow up after “let me think about it”
By Hamza JavedUpdated 3 min read
The short answer
Send three calm messages over ten days, then stop: a short recap on the same day, something genuinely useful on day 3, and one final, no-pressure check-in on day 10. Each message should give the person something rather than ask for a decision, so they can decide in their own time without feeling chased.
Key points
- Same day: a recap of what you talked about.
- Day 3: one useful resource linked to their goal. No reply needed.
- Day 10: one last check-in with your booking link. Then stop.
- No fake deadlines, no discounts to push a decision.
The three messages
Thanks for your time today, [name]. As promised, here’s a short recap of what we talked about: [2–3 points]. Take all the time you need.
Hi [name], I thought this might be useful while you’re thinking it over: [one helpful resource linked to their goal]. No reply needed.
Hi [name], just checking in once more. If now isn’t the right time, that’s completely fine. If you’d like to start, you can book here: [link]. Either way, I wish you the best with [their goal].
Then stop. If they come back in a month, they will remember you as the coach who didn’t chase them.
Why this works
- The recap shows you listened, and gives them something to reread when they decide.
- The day-3 message adds value instead of asking “any thoughts?”.
- The last message makes saying no easy, which takes the pressure off saying yes.
- The clear end protects your reputation. People talk about coaches who chase.
What to avoid
- “Just bumping this to the top of your inbox.” It asks for attention and gives nothing.
- Deadlines that aren’t real. If the price or the spot really ends, say so once, plainly.
- Discounts offered only to push a decision. They teach people to wait.
- More than three messages. After day 10, leave the door open and let them walk through it.
One question to ask before the call ends
When someone says “let me think about it”, ask kindly: “Of course. What would help you decide?” The answer tells you what your recap and day-3 message should cover, whether that is cost, timing or whether coaching is right for them.
How to automate it
Tag the person after the call
In your email tool or client list, add a tag such as “thinking it over”. That tag is the trigger.
Send message 1 yourself
The recap should be personal, so write it by hand. A saved template with the structure makes it a two-minute job.
Let the tool send messages 2 and 3
Set them to go out on day 3 and day 10, using fields like their name and goal.
Stop when they reply or book
Make sure a reply or a booking removes the tag, so nobody gets a check-in after they’ve already said yes.
Common questions
How long should I wait to follow up after a discovery call?
Send a short recap the same day, while the call is fresh. Then a useful resource on day 3 and a final check-in on day 10.
Is it pushy to follow up at all?
No, if each message helps them and the sequence has a clear end. Many people say “let me think about it” and then simply get busy; a calm reminder is a service.
What should I do if they say no?
Thank them, wish them well and stop the sequence. Ask if you can check in again in a few months, and only do so if they say yes.
Written by Hamza Javed, a software engineer who builds automation for coaches and small education businesses: replies to new enquiries, follow-ups and content that publishes itself. More about Hamza